6.2x EV/EBITDA on 2019 numbers, not too far off Townsquare Media's 7.0x. Fairly low numbers. But the bigger question: is radio a sector that you'll want to be invested in, longer-term?
TSQ has fairly high capex that is around 20% of of EBITDA though. SBS it is only about 5%. SBS has ~40% EBIT margins on radio side and TSQ only ~25-30%. SBS ad revenue growth so far is also more impressive vs 2019. SBS has option to sell non core assets, although TSQ does seem to have some NOLS still, so that probably balances out. They do have similar Debt/EBIT multiples though, and TSQ only pays just over 7% on their debt.
Assuming Net debt is $470m YE 2022, TSQ EV/EBIT is about 7.6x While in my YE 2022 base and bull estimate for SBS I get a Debt/EBIT of 5-6x. Assuming they would trade at same multiple by then, upside for SBS would be between 300-500%.
As for radio in general, I wouldn't invest in the industry, but SBS has done rather well so far expanding their audience and increasing ratings. And it is cheap enough that I am not worrying too much about that for now.
Their presentation, although somewhat promotional, has decent statistics on radio usage:
Their strongest outperformance is in 18-34 age group showing 33% ratings growth (see page 21 of presentation). Generally dying industries that are geared towards consumers perform worst among young people. They outperformed every other radio company in terms of ratings, showing overal ratings growth in 2020, and it seems Hispanics use the radio more than other demographics and will show faster growth in buying power compared to the general US population.
I invested in some of these names in last downturn/recovery but the competition was tamer then (not as much podcasting). Do you think this is in terminal decline as revenues continue to decline? Do you think they will generate enough FCF to pay back debt or will they be dependent upon a favorable sale to generate positive returns for shareholders?
I think this risk is mitigated by the fact that they target Hispanics in Spanish language. And have a big focus on music. And so far the trend is up not down in the past years.
For example LaMusica had about 5 million monthly streaming hours in early '19, and in Q2 '21 this was 16 million. This has yet to be fully monetized.
Their presentation mentiones 22% YoY audience growth in radio in June 2020.
AIRE radio served 13.5 million listeners in 2014 and 15 million 2020.
Every call mentions them taking market share and increasing ratings and listener numbers with their radio stations.
So if there is a down trend it has yet to materialize. By the looks of it these guys are turning the screws on their competition, not the other way around. I would be curious what exactly they are doing to achieve these results though. Probably a result of having dominant market share among latino's, exceptional management, radio being a shared live experience and being free.
I think part of it is just the general market. For example audience and listener hours were way up in 2020, but revenue was down due to advertisers spending less due to Covid. And events revenue being zero.
But 2019 radio revenue was up over past 5 3 & 1 year. And Q2 2021 radio revenue was up over Q2 2019 revenue. And if you look at the Q2 call, it appears Q3 2021 is by far going to be the company's best quarter as the COO indicated they had reached Q3 2019 radio revenue's already 2 months into the quarter. And seemed really really excited.
So I think a portion of it is that they have not fully monetized their audience reach, and it does appear that signing up with Katz for their AIRE network has significantly improved this (see also Q1 call). Possibly the debt overhang and negotiations with pref holders were also a distraction/hurt the company? And that is now gone as well.
6.2x EV/EBITDA on 2019 numbers, not too far off Townsquare Media's 7.0x. Fairly low numbers. But the bigger question: is radio a sector that you'll want to be invested in, longer-term?
TSQ has fairly high capex that is around 20% of of EBITDA though. SBS it is only about 5%. SBS has ~40% EBIT margins on radio side and TSQ only ~25-30%. SBS ad revenue growth so far is also more impressive vs 2019. SBS has option to sell non core assets, although TSQ does seem to have some NOLS still, so that probably balances out. They do have similar Debt/EBIT multiples though, and TSQ only pays just over 7% on their debt.
Assuming Net debt is $470m YE 2022, TSQ EV/EBIT is about 7.6x While in my YE 2022 base and bull estimate for SBS I get a Debt/EBIT of 5-6x. Assuming they would trade at same multiple by then, upside for SBS would be between 300-500%.
As for radio in general, I wouldn't invest in the industry, but SBS has done rather well so far expanding their audience and increasing ratings. And it is cheap enough that I am not worrying too much about that for now.
Their presentation, although somewhat promotional, has decent statistics on radio usage:
https://www.spanishbroadcasting.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2020/09/SBS-Investor-Presentation-October-2020.pdf
Their strongest outperformance is in 18-34 age group showing 33% ratings growth (see page 21 of presentation). Generally dying industries that are geared towards consumers perform worst among young people. They outperformed every other radio company in terms of ratings, showing overal ratings growth in 2020, and it seems Hispanics use the radio more than other demographics and will show faster growth in buying power compared to the general US population.
Thanks for your long answer IJW. It does look quite inexpensive
I invested in some of these names in last downturn/recovery but the competition was tamer then (not as much podcasting). Do you think this is in terminal decline as revenues continue to decline? Do you think they will generate enough FCF to pay back debt or will they be dependent upon a favorable sale to generate positive returns for shareholders?
I think this risk is mitigated by the fact that they target Hispanics in Spanish language. And have a big focus on music. And so far the trend is up not down in the past years.
For example LaMusica had about 5 million monthly streaming hours in early '19, and in Q2 '21 this was 16 million. This has yet to be fully monetized.
Their presentation mentiones 22% YoY audience growth in radio in June 2020.
AIRE radio served 13.5 million listeners in 2014 and 15 million 2020.
Every call mentions them taking market share and increasing ratings and listener numbers with their radio stations.
So if there is a down trend it has yet to materialize. By the looks of it these guys are turning the screws on their competition, not the other way around. I would be curious what exactly they are doing to achieve these results though. Probably a result of having dominant market share among latino's, exceptional management, radio being a shared live experience and being free.
https://deloitte.wsj.com/articles/radio-retains-its-appeal-for-consumers-advertisers-01553734927
Why has revenue gone down then over the past 5, 3 & 1 year? Streaming time has gone up but it sounds like ARPU has more than offset this decline.
To be more specific revenue have declined from 2019 levels. TIA.
I think part of it is just the general market. For example audience and listener hours were way up in 2020, but revenue was down due to advertisers spending less due to Covid. And events revenue being zero.
But 2019 radio revenue was up over past 5 3 & 1 year. And Q2 2021 radio revenue was up over Q2 2019 revenue. And if you look at the Q2 call, it appears Q3 2021 is by far going to be the company's best quarter as the COO indicated they had reached Q3 2019 radio revenue's already 2 months into the quarter. And seemed really really excited.
So I think a portion of it is that they have not fully monetized their audience reach, and it does appear that signing up with Katz for their AIRE network has significantly improved this (see also Q1 call). Possibly the debt overhang and negotiations with pref holders were also a distraction/hurt the company? And that is now gone as well.